APPENDIX

Assessment Worksheets
The worksheets for each of the six areas are appended for illustration - two are specific to secondary schools, one for primary schools and four are common to all schools. Electronic versions of these are available from the Scottish Government's school estate website - www.scotland.gov.uk/schoolestate/suitability, or call 0131 244 0877.
SUITABILITY ASSESSMENT - SECONDARY
School: | |
Area: | General Learning and Teaching Spaces( e.g. non-practical classrooms, areas for group work/private study) |
Weighting: | 25% |
Method: | Assess the fitness for purpose of the area by assigning a rating from A to D to each factor, taking account of the illustrations below. The ratings will be aggregated automatically by the electronic spreadsheet to give an overall suitability assessment for the area. |
Illustrations:
Category A: |
Spaces are suitable for all functions/activities that are conducted within them. |
Spaces are conveniently located within the building for access to other areas and for disabled access. |
Spaces are comfortable for users and conditions are conducive to learning and teaching. |
Spaces are safe and reasonably risk-free, with secure areas as required. |
Spaces are fitted out appropriately for activities conducted within them. |
Category C: |
Many spaces are unsuitable for some of the functions/activities that are conducted within them on a regular basis. |
Spaces are often located at an inconvenient distance from each other and there is not disabled access to all curriculum areas. |
Many spaces are uncomfortable for users, with conditions which may inhibit or distract from learning and teaching. |
There are significant unsafe aspects to some areas, and security is incomplete. |
Many spaces lack some necessary fittings for activities conducted within them. |
Factor: | Rating: |
Functionality | |
e.g. shape, size, flexibility, lighting |
Accessibility | |
e.g. ease of access for all, departmental organisation |
Environmental Conditions | |
e.g. temperature, acoustics, ventilation, natural light, controllability |
Safety & Security | |
e.g. windows, fire doors, heat source |
Fixed Furniture & Fittings | |
e.g.ICT infrastructure, storage, display boards, power points |
Comments
Please comment on any issues of particular concern, including any aspect which you have rated as 'D'. |
|
SUITABILITY ASSESSMENT - SECONDARY
School: | |
Area: | Practical Learning and Teaching Spaces( e.g. Art, drama, home economics, music, science, technical, P.E. (internal and external, including courts, pitches, running tracks)) |
Weighting: | 25% |
Method: | Assess the fitness for purpose of the area by assigning a rating from A to D to each factor, taking account of the illustrations below. The ratings will be aggregated automatically by the electronic spreadsheet to give an overall suitability assessment for the area. |
Illustrations:
Category A: |
Spaces are suitable for all functions/activities that are conducted within them. |
Spaces are conveniently located within the building for access to other areas and for disabled access. Location facilitates all normal Learning and Teaching activities. |
Spaces are comfortable for users and conditions are conducive to learning and teaching. |
Spaces are safe and reasonably risk-free, with secure areas as required. |
Spaces are fitted out appropriately for activities conducted within them. |
Category C: |
Many spaces are unsuitable for some of the functions/activities that are conducted within them on a regular basis. Issues of availability can restrict the curriculum. |
Spaces are often located at an inconvenient distance from each other and there is not disabled access to all curriculum areas. Some areas are off-campus. |
Some areas are uncomfortable for users, with conditions which may inhibit or distract from learning and teaching. |
There are significant unsafe aspects to some areas, and security is incomplete. |
Many spaces lack some necessary fittings for activities conducted within them. |
Factor: | Rating: |
Functionality | |
e.g. shape, size, flexibility, changing facilities, lighting |
Accessibility | |
e.g. Ease of access for all, disabled changing facilities and equipment, on/off campus, travel time |
Environmental Conditions | |
e.g. temperature, acoustics, ventilation, natural light, controllability |
Safety & Security | |
e.g. windows, fire doors, surfaces, perimeter security |
Fixed Furniture & Fittings | |
e.g.ICT infrastructure, storage, display boards, power points, specialist equipment/fittings, all-weather facilities, playing surfaces |
Comments
Please comment on any issues of particular concern, including any aspect which you have rated as 'D'. |
|
SUITABILITY ASSESSMENT - PRIMARY
School: | |
Area: | Learning and Teaching Spaces( e.g. classrooms, areas for group work/private study, internal and external P.E./games areas) |
Weighting: | 50% |
Method: | Assess the fitness for purpose of the area by assigning a rating from A to D to each factor, taking account of the illustrations below. The ratings will be aggregated automatically by the electronic spreadsheet to give an overall suitability assessment for the area. |
Illustrations:
Category A: |
Spaces are suitable for all functions/activities that are conducted within them. |
Spaces are conveniently located within the building for access to other areas and for disabled access. |
Spaces are comfortable for users and conditions are conducive to learning and teaching. |
Spaces are safe and reasonably risk-free, with secure areas as required. |
Spaces are fitted out appropriately for activities conducted within them. |
Category C: |
Many spaces are unsuitable for some of the functions/activities that are conducted within them on a regular basis. |
Spaces are often located at an inconvenient distance from each other and there is not disabled access to all curriculum areas. |
Many spaces are uncomfortable for users, with conditions which may inhibit or distract from learning and teaching. |
There are significant unsafe aspects to some areas, and security is incomplete. |
Many spaces lack some necessary fittings for activities conducted within them. |
Factor: | Rating: |
Functionality | |
e.g. shape, size, flexibility, lighting |
Accessibility | |
e.g. ease of access for all, departmental organisation |
Environmental Conditions | |
e.g. temperature, acoustics, ventilation, natural light, controllability |
Safety & Security | |
e.g. windows, fire doors, heat source |
Fixed Furniture & Fittings | |
e.g.ICT infrastructure, storage, display boards, power points |
Comments
Please comment on any issues of particular concern, including any aspect which you have rated as 'D'. |
|
SUITABILITY ASSESSMENT - ALL SCHOOLS
School: | |
Area: | Internal Social Spaces( e.g. pupil social areas, dining/common rooms, staffrooms) |
Weighting: | 15% |
Method: | Assess the fitness for purpose of the area by assigning a rating from A to D to each Factor, taking account of the illustrations below. The ratings will be aggregated automatically by the electronic spreadsheet to give an overall suitability assessment for the area. |
Illustrations:
Category A: |
There are a good range of internal social spaces allowing all to engage in individual or group activities, in out-of-class time. |
Social spaces are available throughout the school and the allocation of these takes account of age, stage and disability issues. |
Internal social spaces are maintained at an appropriate temperature, are well ventilated and benefit from natural light. |
Social spaces are safe and reasonably risk-free, with secure areas as required. |
Fixed furnishings and equipment help facilitate socialising and relaxation. |
Category C: |
Internal Social Spaces exist but are limited in number and range. |
Internal Social Spaces are concentrated in one area of the school and tend to be crowded at break times. Disabled access is possible but difficult. |
Internal social spaces would benefit from better temperature control, better ventilation and more natural light. |
While generally safe and reasonably risk-free,some social areas are secluded. |
The internal social areas have little appropriate fixed furniture and equipment. |
Factor: | Rating: |
Functionality | |
e.g. shape, size and range, lighting |
Accessibility | |
e.g. ease of access for all, age/stage appropriate space |
Environmental Conditions | |
e.g. temperature, acoustics, ventilation, natural light, controllability |
Safety & Security | |
e.g. observed areas, age/stage separation, windows, fire doors, CCTV |
Fixed Furniture & Fittings | |
e.g. Fixed equipment/ fittings for leisure activities/ private study, rubbish bins |
Comments
Please comment on any issues of particular concern, including any aspect which you have rated as 'D'. |
|
SUITABILITY ASSESSMENT - ALL SCHOOLS
School: | |
Area: | Internal Facilities( e.g. reception, administration, office, meeting, circulation space, resource/staff bases, library, toilets) |
Weighting: | 15% |
Method: | Assess the fitness for purpose of the area by assigning a rating from A to D to each factor, taking account of the illustrations below. The ratings will be aggregated automatically by the electronic spreadsheet to give an overall suitability assessment for the area. |
Illustrations:
Category A: |
Reception area, administrative and office accommodation are appropriate. Toilets are user friendly, offering dignity and privacy. |
The location of these facilities within the building offers easy access to all including those with disabilities. |
Internal facilities are maintained at an appropriate temperature and are well ventilated. Noisy equipment, e.g photocopiers are housed separately. |
Areas are safe and reasonably risk-free. |
Fittings in all areas are of good quality. |
Category C: |
The number of toilets while adequate is not ideal. The number of offices while adequate is not ideal. |
Office/administrative space is often unavailable. Toilets are in blocks and not on each level nor adjacent to each teaching area. |
These facilities would benefit from better temperature control, better ventilation. A significant number have no natural light. |
The design of the toilet blocks creates some insecurity among the users. |
Fixed furniture and fittings are dated and would benefit from upgrading. |
Factor: | Rating: |
Functionality | |
e.g. number, shape, size, range, privacy, lighting |
Accessibility | |
e.g. ease of access for all |
Environmental Conditions | |
e.g. temperature, acoustics, ventilation, natural light, controllability |
Safety & Security | |
e.g. secure access control, observed areas, age/stage separation, CCTV |
Fixed Furniture & Fittings | |
e.g. reception window/desk, sanitary ware, fixed office equipment |
Comments
Please comment on any issues of particular concern, including any aspect which you have rated as 'D' |
|
SUITABILITY ASSESSMENT - ALL SCHOOLS
School: | |
Area: | External Social Spaces( e.g. play, covered, seated areas) |
Weighting: | 10% |
Method: | Assess the fitness for purpose of the area by assigning a rating from A to D to each factor, taking account of the illustrations below. The ratings will be aggregated automatically by the electronic spreadsheet to give an overall suitability assessment for the area. |
Illustrations:
Category A: |
There are a good range of open and covered external social spaces allowing all to engage in individual or group games/activities, in out-of-class time. |
These spaces are adjacent to the school and offer easy access to all. There is adequate room for appropriate age/stage separation. |
The location of these facilities is not compromised by particular external environmental factors. |
These spaces are secure and easily observed. |
Appropriate fixed furniture and equipment is provided. Toilet access is adjacent. |
Category C: |
External Social Spaces exist but are limited in number and range. |
External Social Spaces are concentrated in one area of the school and tend to be crowded at break times. Disabled access is possible but not convenient. |
The adjacency of e.g. a main road, railway, flight path affects this area. |
While generally safe and reasonably risk-free, the perimeter fencing is not entirely secure. Some areas are not easily observed. |
The external social areas have limited fixed furniture or equipment. Toilet access is at a distance. |
Factor: | Rating: |
Functionality | |
e.g. size, shape, number |
Accessibility | |
e.g. ease of access for all, space age/stage appropriate |
Environmental Conditions | |
e.g. reference to any external factors affecting the area |
Safety & Security | |
e.g. surfaces, perimeter fencing, ease of observation, CCTV |
Fixed Furniture & Fittings | |
e.g. benches, play equipment, toilets, rubbish bins |
Comments
Please comment on any issues of particular concern, including any aspect which you have rated as 'D'. |
|
SUITABILITY ASSESSMENT - ALL SCHOOLS
School: | |
Area: | External Facilities( e.g. car parks, bike sheds, drop-off areas, storage facilities) |
Weighting: | 10% |
Method: | Assess the fitness for purpose of the area by assigning a rating from A to D to each factor, taking account of the illustrations below. The ratings will be aggregated automatically by the electronic spreadsheet to give an overall suitability assessment for the area. |
Illustrations:
Category A: |
Areas are suitable for all functions/activities that are conducted within them. |
Areas are easily accessed by all users. |
The location of these facilities is not compromised by particular external environmental factors. |
Spaces are safe and reasonably risk-free, there is an effective traffic management system and there is appropriate perimeter fencing. |
Spaces are fitted out appropriately for activities conducted within them. |
Category C: |
Some areas are unsuitable for some of the functions/activities that are conducted within them on a regular basis. |
Some areas are located at an inconvenient distance from each other. Some facilities are off-campus. |
The adjacency of, e.g. a main road, railway, flight path affects this area. |
While generally safe and reasonably risk-free, the perimeter fencing is not entirely secure. |
Spaces are lacking in equipment. |
Factor: | Rating: |
Functionality | |
e.g. size, layout, lighting |
Accessibility | |
e.g. ease of access for all |
Environmental Conditions | |
e.g. reference to any external factors affecting the area |
Safety & Security | |
e.g. surfaces, perimeter fencing, ease of observation, security lighting, CCTV |
Fixed Furniture & Fittings | |
e.g. signage, marked parking bays, bike racks, bin stores |
Comments
Please comment on any issues of particular concern, including any aspect which you have rated as 'D'. |
|