Review of the S1/S2 PSD Road Safety Education Resource

Listen

ANNEX 4 TEACHER TELEPHONE INTERVIEW PROFORMA

Name and school

Authority

Roll

Contact details

Seed Code

DATE

TIME

On behalf of the Scottish Government and Road Safety Scotland

  • Some general questions about PSD and road safety education in your school
  • How road safety resources are used
  • Your opinion on the different parts of the S1/S2 resource
  • How future resources might be developed to assist teachers

A General - Road safety education in the school
(details completed on the postal questionnaire will not be requested during the telephone interview)

1. How is PSD organised in your school?

(Through subjects/specific timetable/tutor group/ mixture etc)

S1

S2

Do you think this will change with the implementation of CfE?

2. How many teachers are involved in teaching PSD to S1 and S2 (Probe on how teachers are assigned - e.g. form tutor / anyone who is available on the timetable

3. What do you think are the key health and wellbeing issues for this age group?

4. Approximately how much time do S1 and S2 spend on PSD?

(number of lessons per week/ school year / length of lessons

5a How much of this time is given to RSE?

5a How does this to compare other issues such as sex and drugs?

5. Are there usually any planned RSE activities beyond the standard curriculum?

(E.g. activity weeks / health and wellbeing projects / external speakers / parental involvement etc)

6. How important do you think it is for this age group to receive road safety education?

B Road safety resources

7. What do you think are the most useful and effective resources you use for supporting PSD teaching? - Not just road safety (Probe as to why a resource is particularly good)

Moving on to talk specifically about road safety resources -

8. Does the school have a copy of the S1 / S2 resource? (Or several copies)

Comment

Yes

No

Where in the school is the resource usually kept and who has access to it?

C Teachers' specific opinions of the S1/S2 resource

9. What do you think of the overall presentation and look of the S1/S2 pack? (external packaging)

10. What parts of the resource have been used by teachers in your school?

( üif used or X if not used or ? if unsure)

For each of the parts that have not been used, please could you briefly say why?

S1 / S2 Resource elements

v
X
?

Comments - probe why not used in any way

Teacher's Notes

Level D Activity 1
Accidents

Level D Activity 2
Travel risks

Level D Activity 3
Good and bad RS behaviour

Level D Activity 4
Child deaths on the road

Level E Activity 5
Cycle Helmets

Level E Activity 6
Laws

Level E Activity 7
Moving from primary to secondary

Script of Nine Lives of Roddy Hogg

TIE Nine Lives of Roddy Hogg

TIE support materials

Additional Comments

11. Please could you now think in more detail about the different parts of the pack? What do you think of the elements of the S1/S2 pack that you have used in terms of how it looks, how useful it has been to you as a teacher or what has not worked so well. We would also like you to suggest any improvements you think could be made.

Format and presentation / Effectiveness - it does what it should / ease of use / Content / Weaknesses / Improvements /Other issues

D How a new resource might be developed

In considering how a new resource for this age group might be developed, I would like to ask you about your views on possible options. First of all I would like to ask some questions about content.

8. What road safety topics do you think are relevant for the S1/S2 age group?

9. Please say whether you think the following topics are very relevant, relevant or less relevant in teaching road safety to this age group.

Topic

Very relevant

Relevant

Less relevant

The Highway Code

Responsible passenger / seatbelts

Cycling issues

Sustainable travel / Using public transport

Poor driving behaviour - speed/drink/drugs

Road accident stats

The effects of alcohol on pedestrians/road users

Planning journeys

The consequences of road accidents

Judging the speed and distance of traffic

Identifying safe places to cross

Seeing and being seen

Looking after younger children

Becoming a driver one day

Distractions: mobile phones/ MP3

Reinforcing lesions learned in Primary school

Other comments

10. Do you think a new resource should be as much concerned with encouraging students to develop social and personal skills to make safer choices as it is about specific road safety issues?

Yes

No

What do you think is especially relevant?

11. I would now like to ask you about ideas for learning and teaching that might be part of a new resource. Please say whether you think the following are very relevant, relevant or less relevant in teaching road safety to this age group.

Method

Very relevant

Relevant

Less relevant

Discussions - what if…

Group activities - research / presentations

Worksheets

Role play / simulations

Theatre in Education

Pledges / Commitment to behaviour change

Interactive whiteboard

Multi-media activities - DVD, newspapers

Involvement with community groups

Peer led learning

Involving parents

Guest speakers - eg RSO/ travel planners/Active schools

Other comments / methods

12. Do you think road safety is relevant to the following curriculum areas

Method

Very relevant

Relevant

Less relevant

Health and wellbeing

Personal Safety

Relationships

Citizenship and enterprise

Literacy and numeracy

Other curriculum areas

13. If the pack includes a DVD do you think it should be in a cartoon /graphics format be totally realistic, or a mixture of both?

14. Do you think there should be specific road safety resources?

15. How useful would it be for you to print out teaching ideas and resources as and when you needed them, either from the web or from a DVD?

16. How useful would it be for you and the students to have access to a road safety website specifically for S2/S2?

17. How do you and other teachers get to learn about new road safety resources?

18. How do you and other teachers tend to learn about other types of PSD resources?

19. Do you think training sessions should be available for teachers when new resources are produced?

20. Have you any other comments or thoughts about resource materials?

THANK YOU VERY MUCH FOR TAKING THE TIME TO GIVE YOUR VIEWS. IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO COMMENT FURTHER AT ANY TIME MY CONTACT DETAILS ARE:

Page updated: Thursday, August 14, 2008