Schools Health and Nutrition: Young People Consultation Feedback

Listen

Appendix 4: Themes & Comments Received for Question 6

Do you think that the people who run schools should be allowed to provide their pupils with free healthy drinks, fruit, vegetables, etc?

Theme

No of Comments within Theme

% of Total

It will promote healthy eating

47

30.12%

Offering it for free will encourage people to eat it

35

22.43%

As long as there is still a choice of unhealthy food

22

14.10%

Keep vending machines

14

8.97%

Shouldn't have to pay for that anyway

9

5.76%

It will cost too much

6

3.84%

The healthy options aren't always healthy

5

3.20%

It helps with behaviour and concentration

4

2.56%

It's unfair

4

2.56%

Might not eat healthily at home

3

1.92%

Some people would rather have unhealthy food

2

1.28%

It's up to the school

1

0.64%

Should have a healthy buffet at break

1

0.64%

Help with weight

1

0.64%

It should be charged at reasonable prices

1

0.64%

It would be open to abuse

1

0.64%

Total

156

Positive

This is another good way to promote healthy eating and best of all, it's FREE so this will definitly encourage young people to eat healthily. Anything for free food!

As long as they didn't get rid of vending machines

Yes, but they should still keep snacks in the school for pupils to purchase at the vanding machines, such as crisps, chocolate and fizzy drinks. As i mentioned earlier it should be all about choice.

Of course they should, but they should still keep the vending machines for other pupils to use.

Again, there should be a choice, They should offer these sorts of foods to young people, but, especially in secondary schools, there should also be vending machines to sell chocolate, crisps and fizzy drinks.

Of course, providing they still keep the vending machines, because as i have already mentioned, it is all about choice.

I think they should offer it to pupils but still keep the not so healthy options in schools like fizzy drinks, chocolate, sweets, etc.

IF EVERY BODY GET FREE MEALS PEOPLE WILL START EATING HEALTHY FOODS AND BE GOOD IN THE INSIDE AND OUTSIDE.

I think that this should be encouraged. Although I feel that again there should be choice and vending machines should still be at a designated part of the school.

Yes that would be good, as long as they schools fizzy drinks, chocolate and crisps in a seperate part of the school.

This would be a fantastic idea. Although I must say that they should still keep the vending machines in Schools. I hope that they do not take the vending machines away, ever!

Free food helps get other people to eat other meals.

yes but they have to be available to everyone.

My school does provide free bread with every meal. If you want children to eat healthily, you should start by offering them good food instead of telling them to buy it.

of course, i am not disputing that, what i am disputing is that there should still be vending machines selling fizzy drinks,etc. There should always be a healthy choice.

Yes because it encourages us to be health and keeps our concentration up with regular healthy snacks.

Yes, as this woudl encourage pupils to come into the dinner hall and maybe buy something else.

I think that pupils shoud be given a piece of fruit, some vegaables and a healthy drink every day.

That would be a good idea, but they should stil have vending machines in schools which sell fizzy drinks, crisps and chocolates like the do now.

it's healthy

it would be encouraging pupils yto eat healthy

Whilst at primary school around three years ago, the healthy fruit for all scheme was trialed. I know that this was a success.

it would encourage more people to eat healthily

Don't see why not, if pupils don't want the healthier meal and the only way to persuade them to go healthier is to give them it free for a short period of time, then yes.

The prices at our dining hall are terrible, they can charge you 50p for a bag or "healthy" crisps, ú1.50 for a tub of "goo" and another 70p for a little bottle of juice, which you can buy at the shop down the road for 40p!!

If they did it would encourage other pupils.

id eat it if it was free

because students take anychance they can 2 get free food (and belive me, ive seen it) and that way they can get free food which are healthy.

Yes, something free is always appealing, and if it is healthy it means that kids are more likely to take it.

If more schools provided students with free healthy food then kids will be less likely to buy sweets and other unhealthy foods and will also be a lot calmer and less hyperactive and also concentrate better (which would be an advantage to the school in the long run <ther statistics>)

It is unfair that you have to pay for water, fruit, water and bread.

But there should still be sugary and diet fizzy drinks, crisps, etc for sale

I don't know if my school does

Because it is helping them have a more healthy lifestyle.

There should still be chips on the menu and vending machines should still contain not so healthy options such as chocolate, Fizzy Drinks and crisps.

There should still be unhealthy snacks and drinks made avaliable for pupils for sale in vending machines.

Of Course. They should still sell fizzy drinks, chocolate and crisps in vending machines.

i think that is a good idea

people are more likely to have healthier things if it is free...a cheaper option

i think everything healthy should be free

so we keep healthy

it should be healthy and promote healthy living

They should still keep the vending machines tho.

It would encourage kids to eat healthier as it doesnt cost and they can get a good mixture of everything.

it would encourage a lot more healthy eating

It would allow people to try an alternative as for some it might be the first time they have tried something. People may also eat the fruit etc instead of a sugary snack at breaks

it would encourage more people to eat and drink healthy things if it were free

WE SHOULD GET HEALTHY FRUIT AND JUICE

Keep the vending machines tho, which have sugary drinks, crisps, chocolate etc. There should always be a choice.

Yes they should be allowed to provide their pupils with free healthy drinks, fruit, vegetables, bread etc. but as before, I don't think it should be a compulsory thing

yes, because it will make the children healthier and give the school a better reputation as a school that cares about its pupils. it will mean that even those who don't have a lot of money will be healthier.

Of course, by all means. They should still keep vending machines in the school for purchasing things.

I think a lot of people would really like that, and if healthy foods were taken around the PSE classes once a week or even made available in the dinner hall every day (like how the primary school pupils get the fuel zone pic'n'mix) then I think a lot more people would eat them and maybe start eating healthy on a more regular basis

Not all pupils may be able to afford the costs.

This would encourage healthy eating. People would try knew things if they didn't have to pay for them.

It would be so cool.

If they did this then maybe they would eat the more healthy things because it is free.

Fantastic idea, however make sure that a choice is make available so have your free healthy food but at the same time have the sweets so Young people are about to choose

Because all these contain lots of nutrients and vitamins and they might not get them at home.

This would encourage more pupils to eat healthily.

my school has done that. They put up the prices of junk food and drinks so the could buy the healthy ffod.

Cos then u dont have to pay for them

It is a great idea because then children are incouraged to eat healthy foods. Where as they might be reluctant to buy these things because of the price

free healthy food and drinks would be good from a pupils point of veiw but it would cost the school a lot of money in the long run.

if the people that run the school want to do so i think it would be a great thing to start up but it is up to them i would certainly try to promote this.

to help us have a healthy diet

then your money won't go as fast!

yes, i think that every break time there should be a healthy buffet, including fruit and vegitables!

THIS WOULD ENCOURAGE MORE CHILDREN TO EAT FRUIT AND VEG.

Junk food is available at very low prices, which is important to school kids. To truly encourage healthy eating, lowering prices or indeed providing them for free, would greatly help. Free water is essential.

If the school provides us with free healthy drinks,fruit,vegetables,bread etc? then the school would be helping the children get healthier. I dont think that the school should just order a geat big box of fruit and veg,they should hand out letters at the start of the week to ask the children what they want if they want anything.they should just have the fruit and veg one day a week to save money but it still helps children get healthy.

em it would encourage us to eat healther food and drink if it was free.

that will keep them healthy and fit and strong

you should provide free healthy food because it will make more people healthy but you can have a mixture.

Yes because it's healthy and if you don't know if you like it you can try it for free.

If healthy food is free most people would probably choose it more than unhealthy foods though it's nice to have treats every so often.

Yes, because it would contribute to a healthy lifestyle

if you want to eat healthy meals then you should be able to get it

yes because if people want kids to be healthy then they should give out free healthy meals but if people dont give them freethen kids will not buy them because they are not free

Yes because it would encourage people to eat healthier foods

Get what you want.

It would keep the pupils healthy and active

if its free you will try it but if its for sale people may not buy it

because if it is free you might try it

yes because their looking after the pupils in the school and it would be kind but i think children should pay 20 pence for fruit at school.

there shoulnt have everything healthy though

because it good 2 eat heathy

you get to taste it for free but if its for sale people may not buy it and may just buy sweets instead of the healthy, free option

Why not? fruit and veg is cheaper than unhealthy snacks.

This is definitely a good idea. Everyone is more enthusiastic about things that are free and it will promote healthy eating in a big way.

To encourage kids to eat healthier.

as it would encourage more people to eat and drink healthily

more appealing if it costs nothing- unhealthy food should be priced higher than the equivalent healthy food

if they get it for free they will try it and maby ask for it ast home if they allready dont get it

I think that if children were provided with healthy food and drink for free, they would be more likely to eat it. People do not always want to buy their own.

I can't see anything wrong with this idea.

yes because some people might not get enough

yes because this might encourage people to eat more healthyer

this will make a lot of pupils healthy

IT HELPS U CONCENTRATE

This Will Stop Cildren Getting Fat

free healthy meals would definitley provide some incentive for kids to eat healthy

to make us healthy

to ensure attentionin classes

Their is hardly any bottles of water avainlable

good for pupils

Sounds like a brilliant idea

it would help promote healthy eating within the school environment.

yes but the pupils should have the coice

if they want us to eat healthy they should be able to provide a healthy choice.

because sometimes if there are free health food on offer more people will get them because they are free and cost nothing and then they might start to eat more healthy food.

yes i am a healthy eater and would always encourage people to eat healthy but everything is a free chioce with what you do with your bodys but there should ne objection to this.

They should be allowed to provide it because that kepps the wannabe healthy kids happy and the other kids happy!There should be a large variety offered in schools!

The school i curently attend (Caldervale High) has a healthy range of food which is also quite expensive and they still have quite a lot of unhealthy foods too.

Yes helathy food should be offered and free. It would also be good if the government would back ta free healthy fodd campaign through out schools in scotland

yes if we want to be healthy then we should get it and if we don't want it and we have to pay for it anyway then it's a bit unfair .

because its healthy

because its healthy and it mit make you eat it.

yes because it is good for you.

I think the people who run the school should have the same meals that the pupils have.

so it encourages people to have a healthy life style

We do get free fruit sometimes.

we should be able to get free fruit without paying for it

There is one thing that annoys me about my school. They occaisonaly do cakes and always have tubs of fruit. When there is cakes, the frut is always more expensive and it is encouragin pupils to buy cakes instead of grapes, melon, kiwi etc.

It would let the children taste the food. They might like it and might start eating more of it at home.

All scottish school aged pupils should have free school meals.

I think if pupils are offered free food then they're more likely to take it because they don't need to pay for it and this is appealing to them. This will also make sure they have a balanced diet.

The aim is to encourage healthy eating, so what bettter way than to make it free, or at least noticably cheaper

Are they not already allowed? I think they should be allowed so that we have other things to eat when we get hungry.

yes because the pupils wont pay for the food that they dont usually

my school is starting to do this with bread and fruit and it is becoming a big hit

Negative

If people want children to eat more healthy they should provide healthy snaks and drinks for free or for decent prices. Giving out free fruit and veg is nothing to make children healthy. Something needs to be done and fast if they want the worlds next generation to survive.

the schools wouldnt make any money

why should they

that also wouldn't be fair

Because some adults might not have money

yeh but we still have to pay about 30p for an apple and kitkats are 30p so id rather have a kitkat

If schools provided free healthy food this may encourage people to try new things.However some pupils may abuse this and it could waste money.

i dont like it

It's unfair to others

No it will cost to much.

people would maybe not want healthy drinks, fruit etc.

Most people don't like healthy things to eat or drink so it's up to them if they want healthy things. It would not be fair on the peole that don't like healthy things as they wouldn't get anything for free.

because why should us pupils who like fruit etc get free food but the pupils who like junk foods have to pay its just not fair.

I can just see it now. 600 children all getting the free food. The dinner ladies need money, too !

but who pays for this

Uncategorised

The people who run schools should think about what kind of food they are putting on the lunch menu. They should concentrate more on meal deals with pasta and bread and lots of whole grain, not chips and burgers. They should use the money spent on greasy foods to buy fresh fruit and vegetables.

Page updated: Friday, October 13, 2006