Scottish Government

ANALYSIS OF RESPONSES TO THE CONSULTATION DOCUMENT 'PROPOSALS TO REVISE EXISTING ANIMAL WELFARE LEGISLATION'

(22) Equal opportunities

Page 11 of the consultation document reported the Executive's policy on equal opportunities. It asked for views on the impact which the proposals may have on equal opportunity issues, especially on guide or other assistance dogs. A number of responders commented on the proposals and their relationship with the Executive's policy:

• Agree that the proposals should not have any direct impact on equal opportunity issues. (Scottish SPCA)

• The proposals do not appear to have any direct impact on this, but views are welcomed on the impact these proposals would have regarding guide or assistance dogs. The legislation could also apply to pets kept in schools, such as accreditation of the skills of those who look after pets. It could also apply to those pets used as therapy in hospitals, hospices and nursing homes. (PDSA)

• The proposals do not appear to have any direct impact on equal opportunity issues. But, we believe that guide or other assistance dogs should be subject to the same welfare provisions as other animals. (West Lothian Animal Rights and Veggies)

• The proposals are not inconsistent with the issue of equal opportunities in relation to assistance and guide dogs. (Kirkwall Dog Training Club)

• Do not think that the proposals would have a deleterious impact on the 'assistance' group of dogs. (individual)

• It is unlikely the proposals would affect guide or other assistance dogs. However, all animals, including those trained to assist physically challenged humans, are entitled to protection. I would hope that adverse stimuli, used in some countries to train primates to assist people, would not be allowed in this country. (Animal Concern)

• It is virtually impossible to keep a clear consistent policy on equal opportunities when working with animals which have a consciousness of their own. It depends on the severity of the handicap in a handicapped person. However, gender equality is possible in able bodied persons. With groups such as guide or other assistance animals that rely on charity for their income there may be cost implications which could just tip the balance. (PAWSI)